Hard Drive, SSD or regular

S

sothwalker

Looking on crucial.com at SSD's and noted that all the recommended
ones -this after they scanned the system- seemed to be 2.5 inches. The
drives in my laptop are more like 2.75".

They said that would not be a problem but I have to wonder.

Anybody got an opinion?
 
A

Allen Drake

Looking on crucial.com at SSD's and noted that all the recommended
ones -this after they scanned the system- seemed to be 2.5 inches. The
drives in my laptop are more like 2.75".

They said that would not be a problem but I have to wonder.

Anybody got an opinion?
I have over a dozen Crucial SSDs in all my systems and laptops. I have
never had a problem installing or using any of them. I started buying
them when they cost twice what they sell for now. I would say you
can't go wrong. You will get better performance if you have SATA 3
interface but not mandatory.

Good Luck.

Al.
 
P

Paul

Looking on crucial.com at SSD's and noted that all the recommended
ones -this after they scanned the system- seemed to be 2.5 inches. The
drives in my laptop are more like 2.75".

They said that would not be a problem but I have to wonder.

Anybody got an opinion?
A laptop uses 2.5" drives.

I gather from reading the dimensional information in this article,
that the "platter" is 2.5 inches, and the exterior packaging has
some other dimension. You could well be right, when you tell us
you see a 2.75" thing. I haven't spent too much time using
my measuring tape on them :)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hard_disk_drive

Drive sizes are 1.8", 2.5", 3.5", 5.25" (we'll ignore the
bigger ones I've played with in the past, such as 8", and
the machine with the removable disk packs). A 1.8" drive
would slosh around inside the laptop bay. The 2.5" should be
a good fit. Desktops can have two sizes of bays, and you can
either fit a 3.5" in a 3.5" bay, or using a "rail kit", fit
it in a 5.25" bay. Optical drives for desktops, are 5.25".
The 5.25" bays also use slides, which come with the computer
case parts kit.

*******

A critical dimension for a laptop owner, is thickness. The 2.5"
drives might come in 9.5mm or 12.5mm thick. Sometimes, a user
will come in here, and report they got a 12.5 by accident and
it doesn't fit their 9.5mm deep bay. (In some cases, you can
grind some excess structural plastic out of the bay, to make
room, but I digress.) SSDs can be even thinner than that, such
as 7mm. If you buy a 7mm, and if it has screw holes on the side,
it might still fasten to the metal tray they use in the laptop.
With a little forethought and research, the mechanical details
of your purchase, won't be quite as much of a shock.

*******

The tiny 1.8" form factor, uses a microSATA connector.
When it comes to SATA drives, the sizes bigger than that,
all use the same standard. Whereas, at 1.8", there is a
smaller connector. An adapter cable is required, and
some buyers discover they have to buy the adapter cable
from a different company than their drive. So if you
see any "bargain" 1.8" drives, don't forget to include
the cost of cable and shipping, in your budget. The drive
ends up not being quite as cheap as a result. (And if you sit
it in your laptop, it might need a small adapter kit to hold
it in place in the tray. I haven't researched that part.)

Mounting SSDs in a desktop is easy. Just use a nylon tie,
to fasten the drive to any available "post" in the case :)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cable_tie

Paul
 
Y

Yousuf Khan

Looking on crucial.com at SSD's and noted that all the recommended
ones -this after they scanned the system- seemed to be 2.5 inches. The
drives in my laptop are more like 2.75".

They said that would not be a problem but I have to wonder.

Anybody got an opinion?

Yeah, the 2.5", or 3.5" or whatever other dimensions listed are standard
platter dimensions for a rotating hard drive, but of course an SSD
doesn't have any platters, so they are just referring to the standard
listed dimensions. The actual external dimensions maybe different, not
necessarily exactly the same as what's listed.

Yousuf Khan
 
B

BillW50

A critical dimension for a laptop owner, is thickness. The 2.5"
drives might come in 9.5mm or 12.5mm thick. Sometimes, a user
will come in here, and report they got a 12.5 by accident and
it doesn't fit their 9.5mm deep bay. (In some cases, you can
grind some excess structural plastic out of the bay, to make
room, but I digress.) SSDs can be even thinner than that, such
as 7mm. If you buy a 7mm, and if it has screw holes on the side,
it might still fasten to the metal tray they use in the laptop.
With a little forethought and research, the mechanical details
of your purchase, won't be quite as much of a shock.
Actually I am looking right at a 2.5 inch 15mm thick hard drive right
now. It is a Seagate ST1000LM010 or also known as a FreePlay 1000gb. Gee
here are 15 of them I just found right here below. I am sure it isn't
the only 2.5 inch 15mm drives out there.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/350585693057
 
P

Paul

BillW50 said:
Actually I am looking right at a 2.5 inch 15mm thick hard drive right
now. It is a Seagate ST1000LM010 or also known as a FreePlay 1000gb. Gee
here are 15 of them I just found right here below. I am sure it isn't
the only 2.5 inch 15mm drives out there.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/350585693057
Yes, 15mm is mentioned in the Wikipedia article. And
I notice your Ebay item, there's no warning about it either.
I bet that's caused a few unhappy customers.

Paul
 
C

charlie

Yeah, the 2.5", or 3.5" or whatever other dimensions listed are standard
platter dimensions for a rotating hard drive, but of course an SSD
doesn't have any platters, so they are just referring to the standard
listed dimensions. The actual external dimensions maybe different, not
necessarily exactly the same as what's listed.

Yousuf Khan
Some of the newer OEM laptop drives are "skinny" in height, width, and
depth, compared to the older ones. Modifying the laptop case may be
viable. (Or Not!) if this is a problem. On my old (2007) HP9650 laptop,
a Kingston "Hyper-X" and a Chronos SSD fit inside the shields and
adapters as if they were the original hard drives.
 
D

Don Phillipson

Looking on crucial.com at SSD's and noted that all the recommended
ones -this after they scanned the system- seemed to be 2.5 inches. The
drives in my laptop are more like 2.75".

They said that would not be a problem but I have to wonder.
So you expect Crucial to welsh on their money-back guarantee?
 
S

sothwalker

So you expect Crucial to welsh on their money-back guarantee?

No, not at all. I just don't want to have to return something.

I have been using Crucial for about 10 years and their products and
service has been excellent but when I don't understand something I ask
questions. I don't want to wish I had later.
 
J

J. P. Gilliver (John)

In message <[email protected]>,
No, not at all. I just don't want to have to return something.

I have been using Crucial for about 10 years and their products and
service has been excellent but when I don't understand something I ask
questions. I don't want to wish I had later.
As another has said, the 2.5" refers to the size (diameter) of the
actual disc platters inside the unit. The outer case is indeed about
2.75" - wide, somewhat more long. And, as another has said, the
thickness can be one of about three different values.
--
J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()AL-IS-Ch++(p)Ar@T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

The main and the most glorious achievement of television is that it is killing
the art of conversation. If we think of the type of conversation television is
helping to kill, our gratitude must be undying. (George Mikes, "How to be
Inimitable" [1960].)
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Top