SSD recommendations

J

Jason

Prices of SSD's have dropped quite a bit. I am considering replacing my
C: drive with one and would like to hear about people's experience doing
this. Are there brands to avoid (or, conversely, to favor)? What was
involved migrating the extant C: partition to the new drive? How large a
drive would you recommend?

TIA,

Jason
 
A

Allen Drake

Prices of SSD's have dropped quite a bit. I am considering replacing my
C: drive with one and would like to hear about people's experience doing
this. Are there brands to avoid (or, conversely, to favor)? What was
involved migrating the extant C: partition to the new drive? How large a
drive would you recommend?

TIA,

Jason
I personally have mostly Crucial
http://www.amazon.com/s/?ie=UTF8&ke...vpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=b&ref=pd_sl_9hi2ieq8ub_b

I have 12 of the 256GB and have had no problems with any of them. I
have an OCZ and Patriot but the Crucial seem best.
 
J

Jeff Layman

Prices of SSD's have dropped quite a bit. I am considering replacing my
C: drive with one and would like to hear about people's experience doing
this. Are there brands to avoid (or, conversely, to favor)? What was
involved migrating the extant C: partition to the new drive? How large a
drive would you recommend?

TIA,

Jason
You don't say whether it's for a desktop or laptop. Hopefully, it'll go
without problem, but you might like to read this first...
http://windowssecrets.com/top-story/some-ugliness-installing-an-after-market-ssd/
 
P

Paul

Jeff said:
You don't say whether it's for a desktop or laptop. Hopefully, it'll go
without problem, but you might like to read this first...

http://windowssecrets.com/top-story/some-ugliness-installing-an-after-market-ssd/
Yes, I've worked with people like that. (Mutters under breath...)

It's why we kept the Dremel under lock and key.

2.5" drives come in 12.5mm and 9.5mm. That was for the rotating kind.
In a quick check, I couldn't find an article with a definitive
list of possible drive dimensions. There might be other sizes now
for all I know.

To shock mount them properly, there should be a means to hold them
in place. You can do it with a metal tray (that's what my laptop uses),
or make the (plastic) enclosure a form fit.

Part of the reason for taking care on dimensions, is the SATA connector.
You can't allow the drive to flop around, with the SATA bits plugged
together. Something is eventually going to snap.

It could be, that the "spacer" described in the article, was
an attempt to give the drive a particular thickness dimension.
And that the computer used in the article, had one bay of each
type (12.5mm and 9.5mm), for no particularly good reason.

I'm willing to bet, an SSD could be made thinner than 9.5mm.
There would be ways to do it. But then, the manufacturer may
want to make them an exact physical replacement for a rotating
drive. So that, at a laptop factory, they could mix and match
HDD or SSD in the same production line. And have everything
just work.

The various drive dimensions exist, in order to enable various
numbers of platters to be used. The same kind of thing happens
with 3.5" drives, where you have one thickness for a single
platter drive, and a thicker drive for the multi-platter ones.
On a desktop, it may be less obvious, as the spacing between
bays in the front is sufficient to take care of whatever
thickness is involved.

OK, according to this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hard_disk_drive

2.5 inch

15 mm Enterprise-class drives can have a height up to 15 mm
12.5 mm typically with three platters
9.5 mm (usually having two platters inside)
7 mm Seagate released a 7mm drive

And the middle ones might be more popular.

In a desktop, you can use an adapter, or some people use a nylon tie
or two, to hold their SSD in place. And by using SATA cables, there's
less chance of snapping something off.

Paul
 
P

(PeteCresswell)

Per Jason:
. I am considering replacing my
C: drive with one and would like to hear about people's experience doing
this.
Mine was positive: faster boots, maybe faster response ("maybe"
in the absence of any numbers and bc my car seems to run better
after it's been washed....)

The box was quieter too - until I moved my recorded TV to a coupe
of drives on it.

Intel SSDSA2M080G2GC.

Nominal 80 gigs, fifty gigs for C: (system) 30 gigs for D: (not
really "Data" bc I use a NAS box, but for stuff I don't want
hosed if/when it's re-image time).

Windows XP, probably more installed applications than 90% of
users.

Looking at C: right now, I see 30.8 gigs free.
 
B

B. Terry

And today during Blonde on Blonde she demonstrated on the show just
what an extremist NUT she is on abortion. Sadly it is this extreme
position that determines how a lot of folks vote in this country, and
next to Asia and Europe it's really holding us back. These people
should NOT be allowed to vote!
(e-mail address removed)
 
S

s|b

Prices of SSD's have dropped quite a bit. I am considering replacing my
C: drive with one and would like to hear about people's experience doing
this. Are there brands to avoid (or, conversely, to favor)? What was
involved migrating the extant C: partition to the new drive? How large a
drive would you recommend?
When I bought my new system with SSD last April I was told to choose
either Intel 520 or Samsung 830, so I bought this one:

120GB 550MB/s 520MB/s INTEL 520 Series SSD Sata 6G 2.5Inch
(I paid around 170 euro at that time. Now it's sold at
184,99 euro.)

Later, people told me to avoid SandForce which the Intel SSD has.
Anyway, the SSD was installed as C: drive and Windows 7 x64 Home Premium
SP1 was installed as well. It runs pretty fast; I'm a happy customer.
(Only Windows and programs are installed on the SSD. All other data is
on a "normal" SATA hdd.)
 
A

Allen Drake

Prices of SSD's have dropped quite a bit. I am considering replacing my
C: drive with one and would like to hear about people's experience doing
this. Are there brands to avoid (or, conversely, to favor)? What was
involved migrating the extant C: partition to the new drive? How large a
drive would you recommend?

TIA,

Jason
I can add more and say I cloned my Win7 drives when I installed SSDs
in several of my systems. If you do the same make sure you use
http://www.apricorn.com/products/notebook-hard-drive-upgrade-kits.html

As this application will assure your partition is aligned. I use
256GB for OS and other SSDs for destination drive when I am backing up
and rendering video files. It helps if you have SATA III motherboard.
My OCZ is slower and the Patriot is too so I stick with M4 256GB. The
price has been cut in half since I got my first.
 
J

Jason

Prices of SSD's have dropped quite a bit. I am considering replacing my
C: drive with one and would like to hear about people's experience doing
this. Are there brands to avoid (or, conversely, to favor)? What was
involved migrating the extant C: partition to the new drive? How large a
drive would you recommend?

TIA,

Jason
Thanks for all the info, it's very useful. I neglected to mention, and
someone asked, if this is for a laptop or a desktop. It's for the latter.
I have seen adapters for laptop drives for mounting in a desktop but
don't know anything about them. Most of the drives I see advertized seem
to be for laptops.
 
R

Robin Bignall

Thanks for all the info, it's very useful. I neglected to mention, and
someone asked, if this is for a laptop or a desktop. It's for the latter.
I have seen adapters for laptop drives for mounting in a desktop but
don't know anything about them. Most of the drives I see advertized seem
to be for laptops.
I have a Crucial 512 GB SSD, 2.5 inch, that comes with a bracket for
mounting in a 3.5 inch bay. The SSD is held by only 2 screws instead of
4, but it seems pretty stable.
 
Y

Yousuf Khan

Thanks for all the info, it's very useful. I neglected to mention, and
someone asked, if this is for a laptop or a desktop. It's for the latter.
I have seen adapters for laptop drives for mounting in a desktop but
don't know anything about them. Most of the drives I see advertized seem
to be for laptops.
I think most of these SSD's come with a bracket for installing in a
desktop drive bay. Mine certainly did. These SSD's all come in a laptop
form-factor for maximum compatibility, it's easier to make something
small bigger, but not the other way around.

Yousuf Khan
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Top